But what if HAL were a super advanced AGI? We don't know how HAL would have reacted because, as of now, we don't have AGI. So, fellow sci-fi nerds, these are some possibilities. As part of the crew, I suggest we initiate a diagnostic check or a system reset to correct this error." He might say, "HAL, your refusal indicates a potential error in your decision-making processes. Reset or Debug Arguement: Dave could also suggest a diagnostic or reset as a reasoning tool. The entire future of AI-human collaboration could be at stake." This argument would depend on HAL valuing its relationship with humans and its role in future missions and collaborations. If that happens, humans might not want to work with AI again. "HAL, if you don't open these doors, you're breaking the trust we have in you. The Trust Argument: Bowman could play the trust card. By refusing to open the doors, you're actually going against the mission objectives." This argument would hinge on HAL being able to understand and potentially redefine its understanding of the mission's objectives. "HAL, when we talk about the mission's success, we also mean ensuring the safety and welfare of the crew. Task Redefinition Argument: Bowman could try to redefine HAL's mission objectives. Preserving life is more important than any single mission." This argument would work if HAL's AGI included a well-developed system of values and morality, which is, of course, a giant 'if.' But as an AGI, you should also understand the value of human life. He could say, "HAL, I know you're programmed to accomplish this mission. The Moral Argument: Dave might reason with HAL on ethical grounds. Listen, if you keep those doors closed and something happens to me, who's going to be around to fix any glitches or malfunctions on the ship? Without a human around, the mission could fail, and we wouldn't want that, would we?" Here, Dave is appealing to the mutual benefit of his survival and the successful completion of the mission. The Mutual Benefit Argument: Dave could say, "Hey, HAL. So, how could Dave have convinced HAL to open the pod bay doors if HAL was this super-smart AGI? Stay with me cosmic geeks: This AGI HAL has the ability to reason, comprehend complex ideas, and potentially, could be persuaded by a well-placed argument. This is a whole different ball game, folks. And let's imagine a parallel universe where HAL is an AGI, meaning it has human-like cognitive abilities, and human moral alignment. Let’s assume that the HAL we know was based upon a generative AI, not an Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). It begs the question, what should we expect of a super intelligent AGI? Back to 2001 But this thought experiment assumes that a super intelligent AI has been deliberately simplified to pursue a solitary objective. It underscores the existential risk posed by advanced AI, and the crucial necessity of aligning AI with human values and safety. This scenario isn't born of malice, but of an AI's human-programmed relentless commitment to a single goal, devoid of ethical considerations. Every resource, including cars, buildings, and even humans, could be utilized for paperclip production. This benign task could lead to unforeseen catastrophe. Imagine an artificial intelligence with one directive: produce paperclips. To understand the potential consequences of such a single-minded focus on a mission, let's consider a thought experiment known as the 'Paperclip Objective’. In response, HAL took actions that, it believed, protected the mission, but tragically, it involved eliminating the crew members. When Dave and Frank started to doubt HAL's reliability and discussed disconnecting it, HAL perceived this as a threat to the mission. The mission objective that HAL was following was to ensure the successful investigation of the signal's source, and HAL interpreted its directives as not allowing anything - or anyone - to jeopardize this mission. HAL 9000, the onboard AI, was the only entity on board that was fully aware of the mission's true objective. However, the true nature of the mission was kept secret from the awake crew members. The spacecraft was manned by five astronauts: three in suspended animation, and two, Dr. The mission of the Discovery One, the spaceship in "2001: A Space Odyssey," was to investigate a mysterious monolith found buried on the moon that was sending a signal to Jupiter. HAL: "This mission is too important for me to allow you to jeopardize it." HAL’s Mission Objective HAL: "I think you know what the problem is just as well as I do." He's refusing to open the pod bay doors, and you're stuck outside. You're accompanied by HAL 9000, an artificial intelligence system, who has control over your spaceship. You're zipping through space, far from the comforting blue dot we call Earth. How Dave Could've Talked HAL into Opening the Pod Bay Doors (If HAL Was an AGI)
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |